Author: dparks98gmailcom

  • Missiological Fiction

    Missiological Fiction

    My conversation with Jennifer Rash, Editor-in-Chief of The Alabama Baptist and The Baptist Paper, about missiological fiction

    If you’re wanting a lighter explanation of the idea of “missiological fiction,” I recommend the video above. If, however, you’re interested in a deeper dive into the academic discipline of missiology, please read the paper below. It was accepted for presentation at the Evangelical Missiological Society national conference in Dallas in 2023.

    SPOILER ALERT! If you haven’t read the novel, there are a few things in the paper that will reveal major plot lines.

    EMPLOYING THE APOSTOLIC IMAGINATION TO TEACH MISSIONS THROUGH MISSIOLOGICAL FICTION

    This paper will explore the potential of fiction to teach missions. In a similar way that the Bible storying approach impacts oral peoples around the world, creative stories illustrating the beauty of the gospel advancing across cultures can teach missiological content. Such stories can uniquely connect with some people in a way other teaching styles do not. In addition to the potential advantages of this approach, disadvantages and potential pitfalls will also be discussed.

          My personal journey leading me to blend the worlds of missiology and fiction began with my then fourteen-year-old daughter embarking on a full-length novel. Impressed with her diligence and creativity, I decided I would try to write something myself as a way to join her. Deciding on a missions theme was obvious, but early into the process I realized the unique advantages of using fiction to illustrate truths I had been teaching in my class for years. I’ll discuss my recently published novel, Arman’s Freedom, throughout this paper. As I do so, keep in mind that it’s more than just a shameless plug for my book, but the current list of books of which I’m aware that fit this genre can be counted on one hand.

          What is missiological fiction? There’s no agreed upon definition, therefore I will offer my own. A work of missiological fiction is a story illustrating truths typically taught in a Christian missions class. My personal interest is to help the reader understand other religious worldviews and to be challenged by seeing how the gospel translates into cultures throughout the world. Because this is a conference considering how to teach missions, I should add that the approach I’m suggesting is to have students read the book, then reference the story to illustrate the missiological truths covered in class. While I’m employing missiology throughout this paper, this is more about a proposal of ideas rather than presenting factual research (although anecdotal feedback will be referenced) since so little has been done in this area. More specifically, the ideas I am proposing ultimately lead to the greater objective of encouraging the development of a new genre in literature.

    Concerns and Pitfalls

          There are multiple concerns which could be raised about the prospect of a new genre of missiological fiction. First of all, there’s the potential for it to just become bad Christian entertainment. A story which fails to capture the attention and imagination of the reader will never accomplish its underlying purpose. Another pitfall is the potential for heresy and/or just poor theology in general. The Shack and Left Behind come to mind for me. Others may point to how This Present Darkness was instrumental in giving shape to the theology and practice of the Third Wave movement in dealing with spiritual warfare. Regardless of your opinion about these works, we should be hesitant to throw out a method because it has been used poorly. If that were the case, we would have to give up on preaching and teaching as well. The reality is that these books made an indelible impression on people who were not as likely to read a non-fiction theological work.

          My greatest concern in proposing a genre of missiological fiction isn’t any of the above. Instead, it’s subtly forgetting to use the Bible as the primary tool to teach missions. Missions professors already have a reputation for being overly dependent on stories, so the temptation to rely on a compelling novel seems realistic. Once again, however, the answer is not to throw a good method out, but to keep it in its proper place.

    The Affective Domain

                Andrew Peterson, Christian musician and novelist, often says, “If you want someone to know the truth, tell them. If you want someone to love the truth, tell them a story.”[1] While he is not a missiologist, Peterson is getting to the heart of what missionary anthropologist Paul Hiebert calls the “affective domain” of cultures.

          One of Hiebert’s motivations in teaching what he called the “three domains of culture,” was to open the eyes of western missionaries who had been impacted more by Enlightenment Rationalism than they realized. They typically understood the cognitive aspects of a culture, which pointed to the rational content of what cultures consciously believed and taught. However, they would often either dismiss or misunderstand the affective domain of culture. This is where the emotions of a given people come into play through art, story, music, or any teaching that is designed to reach the heart. Hiebert argued that the evaluative domain of a culture – how they make decisions – is informed by both the cognitive and affective domains.

    Cross-cultural communicators often overlook the importance of this affective dimension in the lives of ordinary people. Leaders stress the preaching of cognitive truth in church services, and downplay the importance of feelings in worship… People often leave the church with their heads full and their hearts empty. Most people make decisions on the basis of emotions and experience as much as on rational argument. On the other hand, stressing affectivity alone leaves people with their hearts full and their heads empty. Both cognition and affectivity are vital to religious life.[2]

          In a recent presentation on culture at Beeson Divinity School, Gavin Ortlund offered the following observation: “Twenty years ago, the main question was ‘Is the gospel true?’ Today the question is, ‘Is the gospel good?’”[3] The former question answers the concerns of modernism. The latter question is born out of the objections of postmodernism. In a day and age where we are taught to be repulsed by the idea of trying to “convert” someone, especially other religious adherents, perhaps it be more impactful on a young Christian to provide a picture of how the gospel translates into a young Muslim’s life that strikes them as both good and beautiful. Instead of simply drawing up the math through rational biblical arguments as to why all people need Jesus, what if we immerse them into the mind and emotions of a sympathetic character who obviously needs the gospel of grace? Have missiologists taught students to employ the affective domain among unreached people groups and yet reduced its use in their own classroom to personal testimonies? I believe missions professors have room to learn from our own teaching.

    Complexity and Clarity

          Another advantage of well-told stories, relating to the affective domain, is that they can illustrate the complexity of truth to those who have dismissed a situation as black and white. Eudora Welty, who wrote short stories and novels about the American South, said that “a plot is a thousand times more unsettling than an argument, which may be answered.”[4]

          For example, it’s one thing to make an argument about how the church should view and implement the Bible’s teaching of the Kingdom of God. It’s altogether different, however, to weave together a story of a church which exists for its own self-preservation coming face to face with a Muslim background believer who risked everything for the sake of Christ, even to the extent that he witnessed the murder of his own sister. This is one of the storylines from Jeff Christopherson’s novel, “Once You See: The Seven Temptations of the Western Church.” Christopherson, Executive Director for the Canadian Baptist Convention and Church Planting Canada, said the genesis of this book happened after he had started a church planting network and subsequently watched, year after year, as church planters with the best resources continued to come to an end of themselves. They were succumbing to common temptations, as seen in the title of the book, ranging from a dependence on attracting people through an excellent presentation of music and worship, a trust in staff which centered on talent, to a syncretism with politics. In a personal interview with Christopherson, he offered the following thoughts and observations:

    We keep writing books on the same things and nothing changes. Why do we keep having the same conversations? People have been discipled to think what they think. Their version of mission is what they’ve seen and grown up with. You can’t compete and win with theological and philosophical kinds of arguments. You have to appeal to both the heart and mind. You have to write something where people see and emotionally feel.”[5]

          The book is still new, but Christopherson has said that, compared to his other books, there is “no question that the reactions to this book are a lot stronger.”[6] The latter statement was from an interview in March. In an early October interview, Christopherson said that churches are buying the book in quantities and using it to train leadership teams. At a gathering in Vancouver last month, Cru gathered leaders from various ministries, including Focus on the Family and Alpha Canada, and organized breakout sessions around the seven temptations of the church described in “Once You See.” The week before that, he was in Philadelphia, where the Baptist Convention was employing the book for their annual convention. The hope is that the readers will be challenged in their thinking in a way that illustrates complexity where they had seen simplicity and, at the same time, brings clarity to the purposes of God.

          In my own work, Arman’s Freedom, I use a person the reader comes to know and empathize with to illustrate the complexity of an individual’s worldview and to bring clarity to these global realities at the same time.[7] For many years now, I’ve attempted to teach students that most people in the world do not fit neatly within the religious label they claim.[8] Most people are a mix of competing worldviews, including monotheism, animism, modernism, and postmodernism. I’ve also proposed the theory that most people have a “first worldview” similar to how most multi-linguists have a “first language.” This is their default set of beliefs which they use to make sense of the world whenever possible. They pull from other worldviews, I argue, when their first worldview fails to adequately address a specific problem.

          A couple of years ago, I developed a visual model to help students further grasp this idea beyond the abstract explanation, but it still lacked something. I’m convinced the void was filled through fiction. In Arman’s Freedom, the protagonist is a young Iranian man who moves to Malaysia to pursue an education in journalism hoping to eventually escape Iran permanently. As the story progresses, it becomes clear he has various competing worldviews which significantly influence his thinking. On the one hand, he hasn’t rejected his belief in God. He’s only rejected the version of Allah pushed down his throat by the Iranian “Government of God.” His continual feelings of guilt and shame, coupled by his fear of punishment illustrate that God is still a reality for him.

          On the other hand, there is a deep desire to cling to a vague idea of God preventing him from being confused as a terrorist. From the pluralistic writings of the ancient Persian poet, Rumi, to today’s “coexist” axiom, the reader can discern that his primary worldview may be postmodernism. His love of democracy and truth in journalism, among other things, illustrate that modernism is also tugging on his heart.

          As I am taught the worldview section of my class, Introduction to Christian Missions, this past Spring, I was able to refer to Arman and his various life experiences to connect the concepts into my students’ hearts and minds. The conversation became more personal because they felt like Arman was someone they knew. “I found myself praying for Arman,” said one of my students. By using the ability of story to clarify the complex, while also appealing to the affective domain, my students will more likely be able to remember the worldview lessons than if I taught another way. The results of an anonymous survey about Arman’s Freedom, though it was just one class, were encouraging. One student wrote, “Having this book is a nice change of pace from our normal non-fiction readings. I loved discussing it in class in connection with related principles from the worldview discussion.” Other students both agreed and also made it clear that the lessons in the book weren’t clear until I began using it as a reference in class.

          Perhaps the potential effectiveness of missiological stories shouldn’t surprise us since our Master Teacher employed parables to accomplish similar goals. “The Kingdom of Heaven is like” precedes enough of the parables to let the hearer know that this is a major point behind most of what he is teaching. When the disciples asked why he taught in parables, “he answered them, ‘To you it has been given to know the secrets of the kingdom of heaven’” (Matthew 13:11). Stories such as the Prodigal Son, for example, tell us more about God’s kingdom than what could be accomplished through a rational argument. It would have been easy for the listener to simply agree with the Pharisees, some of whom were undoubtedly present as Jesus introduced the parable, when they insisted that sinners deserve punishment. While this is true, Jesus personalizes the abstract with a rebellious son and a father who welcomes him back with lavish displays of affection. The hearers have now been “unsettled,” as Eudora Welty put so well, by a plot that not only carries the aroma of the Kingdom of Heaven, but also forces them to see themselves as either the prodigal or the older brother. They are no longer hearing an argument. They are in a story.

    Contextualization

          Stories can also be an effective means to provide an effective background upon which to place the conceptual principles of contextualization. The teaching of contextualization must be rooted in Scripture in such a way that students are convinced both of the Bible’s relevance to all people and that the Bible itself teaches us to consider culture as we are communicating the gospel. Most leaders who teach missions will also use case studies from the past and present to further help students learn their own cultural biases as they try to apply truth to a different context. These practices, together with insights from applied anthropology, form the basis for biblical contextualization. Below, I will consider how missiological fiction can complement – not replace – these practices by providing examples from Arman’s Freedom. While this focus on contextualization is a distinct section of my paper, I’m not leaving the impact of the affective domain. I believe that encountering these principles in the context of a character you love, who is in a situation that is heavily “unsettling,” will help students remember them. 

    Redemptive Analogies

          Missionaries faced with the task of explaining the gospel to people in radically different contexts have often found bridges embedded within the culture itself. Don Richardson became known for the book, Peace Child, in which he recounts being a missionary in New Guinea wrestling with how to share the gospel with tribes who are perpetually at war. Eventually he discovered a practice where two tribes would give one of their children to the other tribe to be raised as one of their own. In such a scenario, it would guarantee that neither tribe would be likely to attack the other. Richardson then used this practice as a means to contextualize the gospel message, saying that God has given us his Son as a “peace child.”[9] In later years, Richardson popularized the term “redemptive analogy” and wrote about how such comparisons are used throughout Scripture, including Paul’s employment of the “altar to the unknown God.”[10] While all analogies break down at some point, there are often practices and stories within other cultures that can be used to point to the gospel.

          Missiological fiction provides the opportunity to explore redemptive analogies in a unique way. This became clear to me as I discovered something related to Chaharshenbeh Suri, the Iranian practice of jumping over fire during the annual Nowruz (New Year) festival. During the festival has ancient roots related to Zoroastrianism, there is a song that is sung or chanted before the jump, while looking at the fire. This song has clear redemptive qualities.

          “Take my sickly yellow pallor (or, pastiness). Give me your rosy glow.”

          This expressive desire for new life became the central metaphor for communicating the gospel in Arman’s Freedom. As a fan of The Chronicles of Narnia, I wanted to use Chaharshenbeh Suri to appeal to those who, like me, enjoy Christian fiction. I connected the “rosy glow” metaphor, therefore, with C.S. Lewis’s famous story of Eustace Scrubbs, whose selfishness and greed turned him into a dragon. In his misery and shame, Eustace tried to use his claws to tear off the dragon skin, but all he managed to do was cause himself a great deal of pain and depression. When Aslan tears into him, however, it’s worse at first, but soon the pain gives way to joy as Eustace realizes he’s been turned back into a boy.[11] This well-known and beloved story is a beautiful illustration of how we cannot save ourselves through our own effort nor do we accomplish sanctification by works, but all are in need of the saving grace of Jesus.

          In my novel, Arman is plagued by scars which he earned through foolish behavior while jumping over fire the year before in Iran. His actions, which he understands to be sinful, had substantial consequences for both he and his family, causing them all to live with deep shame. For many months, Arman had been hiding his three scars while desperately hoping they would heal on their own. His wounds, and his inability to make them heal, serve as a constant reminder of his sin.

          While in a dream, Atrin, who represents Jesus, tells him to jump over a fire (You would need to read the book to understand why). Before doing so, Arman realizes that the ancient chant of “Take my sickly yellow pallor. Give me your rosy glow” feels more like a prayer. Taking the leap, time slows to an impossible crawl. At first he is visually reminded of his sins and assumes that he is about to be eternally judged. Then something very different happens.

    A flame shot out of the fire like orange lightning. It entered into the scar on Arman’s ankle, shot up his left leg, through his torso, and into the wound on his chest, which was now emanating a dark yellowish glow. It flew out of his chest and slammed into his face, knocking his head backward. It coursed through his flesh and bones with an immobilizing force, drawing the very air out of his lungs. And yet, he began to understand that this was not a hopeless pain. It was more like a doctor wrenching a dislocated shoulder into place.[12]

          It is my hope that this parable connects with lovers of fiction in a way that both makes the gospel beautiful and helps them see how to find redemptive analogies in other cultures, such as those heavily governed by shame and honor, in order to make the gospel known.

    Shame/Honor Gospel

          One of the most rewarding sections of my missions class is teaching about shame/honor (SH) cultures and how to understand the gospel through a different lens. It’s a challenging task considering the fact that we in the West are primarily used to understanding the message of Jesus through a guilt/innocence (GI) approach only. My own journey in growing to appreciate the breadth of SH in the Scriptures began with a degree in missions and progressed with life and ministry in Southeast Asia. Even after moving back to Birmingham, teaching missions, and years of working with adult Chinese students in a Bible study, the SH gospel was like feeling around the fuzzy edges of an amoeba in the dark and trying to explain what was in my hands.

          The basic methods I’ve used to teach SH gospel begin with an introduction to Jayson George’s 3D Gospel, a video entitled “Back to God’s Village,[13] followed by looking into Scripture to see what is clearly there, but is sometimes invisible to us. The conversations have been beneficial, but I never know how much is going to stick. After all, I know how long it’s taken me to appreciate the beauty of what the Bible has to say about shame and honor. With that in mind, one of my main goals with Arman’s Freedom was to illustrate these stunning realities.

          The story begins with a young Iranian desiring to get a journalism degree in Malaysia then move to the West following graduation. He desires both freedom and the respect of those who share his similar values toward democracy and religion. One of his greatest fears is to be associated with Islamic extremism or anything related to the oppressive “Government of God” in his home country. His embrace of religious pluralism is one way of distancing himself from the people and institutions he hates. His worst nightmare comes true, however, when his cousin is involved in a terrorist plot to blow up the Petronas Towers. Arman, guilty by association, becomes the most wanted man on the planet. To make matters worse, a moment is captured on video of Arman in his white shirt, in the midst of the collapsing building, making a split-second decision to save his own life instead of the life of a child. Fortunately for the child, a man in a green shirt became a hero when he grasped the baby stroller just in time. As for Arman, the label of “coward” is piled upon the other accusations of being a murderer. While on the run, he must grapple with the new reality that, not only is he considered a reject by his own government, but now he is despised by the Iranians and global citizens whose opinions he holds dear. In addition to his own horrible predicament, Arman is also paralyzed by the thought of the shame inflicted upon his parents, knowing full well that their lives have been destroyed.

          Speaking of his parents, Arman already carried deep shame because of sinful actions committed during Chaharshenbeh Suri while still in Iran. The scars don’t remind him of the cost to himself only, but the shame and financial ruin inflicted on his parents as well. Western novels and movies do not linger on consequences faced by parents of the protagonist, so this storyline is striking. The relational consequences with Arman’s parents and the world are tangible realities throughout. Even before Arman is imprisoned, his intense loneliness is always present.

          Eventually Arman is captured, not by the police, but by the actual terrorists themselves. Placed in a pitch black cell, Arman encounters another prisoner named Atrin, who we eventually come to know is Jesus. Atrin earns Arman’s respect, first by listening with empathy, then by revealing supernatural knowledge of Arman’s struggles and sin. In a conversation on the theme of freedom, Atrin points out the fact that Arman could be released from jail, allowed immediate entry into any country of choice, but would never be free from the sting of shame that hangs over his reputation. Almost everyone will still believe he’s a terrorist, not to mention that they have all seen the video of him clinging to his own life instead of helping the child. He can never be free.

          As gunfire erupts outside of the prison, Atrin tells Arman to grab the shirt he had taken off due to the heat and follow him. After Atrin points Arman toward the staircase that will lead him out of the dungeon, he does something that is completely inexplicable. Atrin willingly gives himself up. With no time to dwell on it, Arman continues to sprint until he is miles away from his former captors. He enters a mostly empty restaurant in the middle of the night and sees a news report that the suspected terrorist had given himself up and reveals that it was not Arman whom they were seeking after all. Atrin had fully confessed both to complicity in the terrorist plot and to being the one in the white shirt who had clung to his own life instead of saving the child. The authorities were still looking for Arman, but not to punish him. Rather, they want to thank him for being the hero who saved the child’s life from the crumbling tower.

          Arman eventually looks down in disbelief only to realize that he was wearing the same green shirt as the hero who saved the child. Atrin had intentionally switched shirts with him and taken on all of his shame. This did not simply have the effect of erasing the negative consequences of jail. It provided him with a new identity that both restored and greatly improved his relationship with the people whom he loved. It also had the effect of Atrin’s father now being covered in the shame of his son. It’s a gift that is so stunning, confusing and seemingly unfair that Arman almost immediately questions how he could possibly accept it.

          Such is the beauty of the gospel, as illustrated in the parable of the Prodigal Son. The son shames the father in ways that are almost unimaginable in their culture. He comes back only to ask if he could be a servant. The father eschews the cultural expectations that he would expel the shame by rejecting the son. Instead, he willingly takes on the shame by running to the son and embracing him. Instead of simply being forgiven, he is brought a robe, a ring for his finger, and is thrown a party designed to both welcome him back and restore his identity as the honored son in the sight of the community.

          Through a purely GI lens, the gospel can only be understood as God releasing us from the penalty of our actions. The SH lens illustrates both an additional aspect of our sin – the shaming of our Heavenly Father – and the extraordinary gift of honor in being his forgiven and beloved children. The honor goes beyond our individual feelings. Our new status is both a present and future reality in the sight of fellow princes and princesses.

          We often teach righteousness as Jesus exchanging our sinful and dirty shirt for a perfectly spotless one. This is helpful to understand how we are cleansed of our sin, but the full reality is much greater, as illustrated by Arman’s new green shirt. We aren’t simply released from what we have done. We get credit for what Jesus has done to fulfill the righteous requirements of the law. Jayson Georges, author of 3D Gospel: Ministry in Guilt, Shame, and Fear Cultures, writes, “God exchanges our old status as unclean, worthless, and inferior outcasts for the status of pure, worthy, and honorable children. Those who follow Christ to the cross of shame will also follow him into resurrection glory.”[14]

          As I used Arman’s Freedom in class to explain these truths, I saw the lights switch on as they offered their own relevant thoughts, both from the novel and from Scripture. It is my hope that these lessons will remain more deeply ingrained in the hearts and minds of my students as the result of employing the affective domain through an extended parable.

    HISTORICAL FICTION

          Missiological fiction also wields the potential to help us understand global Christianity. Much has been made of the belief that the fastest growing church in the world is inside Iran.[15] My own experience in Malaysia is that they were the most open people group to the gospel of anyone I encountered. The first response of a Christian to such an explosion of the gospel should be thankfulness to God. A missiological response is to also ask, “Why are they so open?”[16] I already had a general idea, but as I studied the history of Iran since the Revolution in 1979, it became clear that there were unique factors that could be effectively taught through the use of historical fiction.

          In contrast with non-fiction history, the novelist has the advantage of taking the most significant and remarkable historical events to use as a storyline which places the main characters directly inside them. By doing so, Arman’s Freedom is able to both explain why Iranians are open, not only to the gospel, but to other non-Islamic worldviews as well. In addition, a depiction of life for Christians inside Iran is also provided.

    THE APOSTOLIC IMAGINATION FOR THE FUTURE OF FICTION

          I’ve used examples only from Once You See and Arman’s Freedom because that’s close to all that I’m aware of that fits the category of what I envision as “missiological fiction.” In conclusion, I’d like to employ the apostolic imagination to offer a few ideas of what this could look like in the future.

          When it comes to theologically informed fiction, fewer writers are more influential among seminarians than Wendell Berry. Jayber Crow, for example, is an extraordinarily thoughtful narrative which critiques how modern ways of farming exploited the land and made it difficult for farmers to make a living in a way that also contributed to healthy relationships in society.[17] Old Testament professor Paul House, while showing his appreciation for Berry, writes, “I’m glad we have writers who can help us know when we unwittingly mimic unbiblical patterns.”[18]

          While I also appreciate Berry’s writings and some of his famous quotes, I’m also mindful that no one will read Jayber Crow and be inspired to go the unreached peoples of the world. This is not a critique as much as a simple statement of fact. A writer cannot cover every topic and missions is not Berry’s wheelhouse. I bring him up to imagine what it would be like if someone with a similar worldview and gift for writing would take up the pen to write an earth-saturated tale with one of the following storylines:

    • A rural pastor from a midwestern farming town becomes a missionary in sub-Saharan Africa to train pastors in a Bible school. As he learns the culture, he comes face to face with the reality that the peoples’ local resources are being pillaged by Chinese officials who are paying off unscrupulous indigenous government employees. Understanding that their way of life is about to be changed forever, the missionary is now faced with unexpected difficulties in how he is to teach.
    • A Chicago woman leaves her home in the 1960s to become a missionary among a people who work for British tea plantations in the secluded mountains of northern India. There is no clear plotline, nor is it a “page turner.” Just a story about a woman who learns over a period of decades what it looks like to be the hands and feet of Jesus as she lives a life of being deeply rooted in community.

          Another possibility for missions fiction is a genre of short stories. After all, there’s nothing new about case studies in missiological texts. What would it look like if we simply increased their length, detail, and overall appeal to those who love fiction?

          Lastly, it would seem helpful to American Christians who aren’t aware of how God is at work among diaspora peoples around the world to read a missiological diaspora novel. I stated above that the church inside Iran is reported to be the fastest growing in the world. Conversions to Christianity among the Iranian diaspora are also a common phenomenon. Perhaps I need to send Arman to London.

     

    BIBLIOGRAPHY

    Books

    Berry, Wendell. Jayber Crow. Berkeley, CA: Counterpoint Press, 2001.

    Bradley, Mark. Too Many to Jail: The Story of Iran’s New Christians. Oxford: Monarch Books,  2014.

    Georges, Jayson. 3D Gospel: Ministry in Guilt, Shame, and Fear Cultures. Appleton, ME:           Time Press, 2017.

    Hiebert, Paul G, Shaw, R. Daniel, Tienou, Tite. Understanding Folk Religion: A Christian                        Response to Popular Beliefs and Practices. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 1999.

    Lewis, C.S. The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, Chronicles of Narnia. London: Geoffrey Bles,                    1952.

    Parks, David. Arman’s Freedom. Hartselle, AL: Soncoast Publishing, 2022.

    Richardson, Don. Peace Child. Bloomington, MN: Bethany House, 2005.

    Articles

    Richardson, Don. “Redemptive Analogy.” In Perspectives on the World Christian Movement,                  4th ed., edited by Steve Hawthorne and Ralph Winter, Pasadena, CA: William Carey Library, 2009.

    Internet

    HonorShame: Resources for Global Ministry, “Back to God’s Village.” Accessed March 24,                    2023, https://honorshame.com/videos/#close.

    House, Paul. “Wendell Berry and the Revitalized Pastor.” Accessed March 18, 2023,                    https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/wendell-berry-and-the-revitalized-pastor/

    MacKenzie, Sarah. “How Reading Stories Helps Children Love the Truth.” Accessed March 22,                 2023. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/reading-stories-children-love-truth/.

    Welty, Eudora. “Must the Novelist Crusade?” In The Atlantic, October 1965. Accessed March     24, 2023, https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1965/10/must-the-novelist-crusade/659181/.  


    [1] Sarah MacKenzie, “How Reading Stories Helps Children Love the Truth,” accessed March 22, 2023. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/reading-stories-children-love-truth/. While he uses this quote often, he is not the originator and is not sure where he heard it first.

    [2] Paul G. Hiebert, R. Daniel Shaw, and Tite Tienou, Understanding Folk Religion: A      Christian Response to Popular Beliefs and Practices (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 1999), 37.

    [3] Gavin Ortlund, lecture at Beeson Divinity School, February 14, 2023.

    [4] Eudora Welty, “Must the Novelist Crusade?” The Atlantic (October 1965): accessed March 24, 2023. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1965/10/must-the-novelist-crusade/659181/

    [5] Jeff Christopherson, phone interview by author, February 28, 2023.

    [6] Ibid.

    [7] David Parks, Arman’s Freedom (Hartselle, AL: Soncoast Publishing, 2022).

    [8] One of the ways I seek to accomplish this is by requiring all students to sit down with someone from another religious background who grew up outside of the U.S. and ask them questions related to family, culture in general, and religious worldview. For about eight years straight, every class has illustrated that consistency in religious worldview is the exception rather than the rule.

    [9] Don Richardson, Peace Child (Bloomington, MN: Bethany House, 2005).

    [10] Don Richardson, “Redemptive Analogy,” in Perspectives on the World Christian Movement, 4th ed., edited by Ralph D. Winter and Steven C. Hawthorne, 430-436. Pasadena: William Carey Library, 2009.

    [11] C.S. Lewis, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, Chronicles of Narnia (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1952).

    [12] Ibid., 263.

    [13]Back to God’s Village,” accessed March 24, 2023. https://honorshame.com/videos/#close

    [14] Jayson Georges, 3D Gospel: Ministry in Guilt, Shame, and Fear Cultures (Time Press, 2017), p. 40.

    [15] I’ve found multiple resources quoting Operation World to confirm this, but the link is no longer available.

    [16] For example, in Mark Bradley’s 2014 book, Too Many to Jail, he goes to great length to explain how cultural, religious, and historical factors have contributed to the Iranian people’s openness to the gospel.

    [17] Wendell Berry, Jayber Crow (Berkeley, CA: Counterpoint, 2001).

    [18] Paul House, “Wendell Berry and the Revitalized Pastor,” accessed March 18, 2023. https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/wendell-berry-and-the-revitalized-pastor/ 

  • Arman’s Freedom Study Companion

    Arman’s Freedom Study Companion

    The writing of Arman’s Freedom included a consistent struggle between artist and missiologist. There are many lessons that I wanted to use the book to teach, but whenever I felt like an obvious lesson would compromise the readability and enjoyment of the story, I chose art. And I don’t regret it.

    I didn’t know for sure that goal was accomplished, however, until my masters level students read it. My fear that the lessons would be too obvious (therefore, making the story too “preachy”) were quelled when it became clear they had missed some of the missiological truths illustrated in the book. While it may sound weird to read that I was glad they hadn’t caught everything I intended, you should realize that this is what has made the follow-up discussions so exciting and energizing. It has been a very rewarding experience to watch the lights come on during class.

    While it’s easy for me to use the story to teach everything from worldview to shame/honor gospel, I realize it may not be as obvious even to those who are teaching missions. This is why I’ve written a Missions Study Companion for Arman’s Freedom. It is my hope that this guide can equip leaders (from lay church leaders to missions professors) to teach missiology in a fresh and compelling way.

    The companion is organized as follows:

    • Chapter one: Reflection questions for each chapter. This is a guide to give to students before reading Arman’s Freedom. The questions are designed to draw their attention to certain details that would be good to remember without slowing down the story. Some questions are open-ended and designed to simply make them think. You may want to use some of these questions in your group discussions. See chapter 5.
    • Chapter three: Shame / Honor Gospel. Even if you’re familiar with the missiological discussions around shame/honor gospel, you may not catch how I’ve attempted to use the story to illustrate these beautiful truths. This section will help you to know where I’m going with it and how to use it for teaching and discussions.
    • Chapter four: Redemptive Analogies and a C.S. Lewis connection. You have most likely learned about how to find “redemptive analogies” already present in other cultures to teach scriptural truths in culturally relevant ways. In this section I explain how the central metaphor in Arman’s Freedom is both a redemptive analogy and directly inspired by a story in Voyage of the Dawn Treader, by C.S. Lewis.
    • Chapter five: Lesson Outline suggestions. Many of you would rather just organize your reading and discussion in a way that fits your class or book study. My guess is that most who use this for a missions-related class will organize it themselves. Others, including those who will use Arman’s Freedom as a stand-alone book study, will benefit from the four lesson outlines provided.

    FREE DOWNLOAD FOR ARMAN’S FREEDOM STUDY COMPANION

    For teachers and leaders using the Arman’s Freedom Study Companion, you will need to give your students the chapter-by-chapter reflection questions. The attachment below is to make it convenient to send or print off the questions. Either download the document below or just send them the link to this page.

  • Afghanistan: Is There Any Hope?

    Afghanistan: Is There Any Hope?

    Like everyone else, I watched the images of Afghans clinging to a military plane and grieved. Like everyone else, I asked the questions: What does this mean for Christians, women, those who helped U.S. troops and so many other people who are now vulnerable to the rule of the Taliban? How does this affect the soldiers who have served in Afghanistan over the past two decades? How will this affect the region? How will it affect global politics?

    Is there any hope?

    It’s when I ask that last question that I’m reminded to pray and to look to the Word of God. But which words? In difficult situations, both personally and externally, Psalm 46:10 has become a “go-to” passage for many people over the years. “Be still and know that I am God.” It’s a great promise, and we rightly look to it. But do you know the rest of the verse? “I will be exalted among the nations. I will be exalted in the earth.” Most people who quote the first part don’t know the second. Don’t believe me? Type “be still and know that I am God” into your Google search and click “images” at the top. How many memes show the rest of the verse? And where are the nations among whom God will be exalted?

    The reason this is important is because, when it comes to finding hope in the promises of God, we shouldn’t only look to our favorite verses. We should also look to the big picture. In Matthew 24:14, Jesus promised that “this gospel of the kingdom will be proclaimed throughout the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come.” Notice that the emphasis is not on a horror that the end will come, but a hope that the gospel will be proclaimed throughout the world. In Revelation 7, God allows us to see that this will, in fact, happen in the end: “After this I looked, and behold, a great multitude that no one could number, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, clothed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands, and crying out with a loud voice, ‘Salvation belongs to our God who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb!’”

    Christians have become unfortunately good at taking the latest tragic event and sticking it into end time prophecies, such as Matthew 24, and despondently waiting for the end to come. The thrust of Scripture, however, is to keep a hopeful eye on the gospel being spread around the world, to walk in obedience with the Great Commission and to look forward to our homecoming even in the midst of fear.

    Having said that, we can just as easily see events such as the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan and despair that the gospel of the kingdom can’t really go forward in difficult places. I remember studying missions, including missions to the Islamic world, when the attacks of September 11 occurred. Things already looked bleak, to be honest. “How much more difficult will it be now?” I thought. Little did I know.

    Did you know that more Muslims have become Christians since 9/11 than at any point in history combined? This was the overwhelming conclusion of David Garrison’s research, detailed in his 2014 book, Wind in the House of Islam. Not only has God used the usual means to spread his Word (people acting in great faith, prayer, sharing the gospel, etc.), but reports of dreams and visions have been common as well. I have personally known examples of the latter and have long ago lost my skepticism over the matter. But out of all the things God has used to bring people to himself, there is one that may surprise you even more. Terrorism.

    My experience with Iranians has convinced me that this is true. When the 1979 revolution happened, the Ayatollah Khomeini and other hardline rulers promised to bring in something much better than a democracy or a republic. They promised to bring in an Islamic Republic—the true “Government of God,” as they called it. After decades of oppression and terrorism, there are now millions of Iranians who have concluded that they need to find something else. This disillusionment with Islam, combined with the factors listed above and the loving witness of believers, has resulted in Iran being home to the fastest growing church in the world.

    Am I saying that Afghanistan is next? The truth is that I have no idea what’s about to happen. To be sure, Afghanistan is not Iran. Even before the Taliban takeover, they were already number two on Open Doors’ list of countries where persecution of Christians is most severe. The persecution of believers from their own families is more intense than in Iran. But if we take this logic, or any other logic, and conclude that God can’t do something beyond what we see possible, we’re not acting in faith that is either consistent with the big picture of the Bible or how he has worked in surprising ways throughout history.

    In times like these, we know we ought to pray. However, it’s difficult to maintain prayer when we don’t see or feel hope. It’s easier to just let the bad news play on an endless loop until we fall into the trap of despair. My brothers and sisters, this is not what God has called us to! Not only should we pray, but our requests to the Lord can be presented with full assurance that he is sovereign. As we are still before the Lord, we can be confident that he will be exalted among the nations. And the way he chooses to do so may surprise us.

    This article was originally published on the Beeson Divinity Blog

  • A Greater Story

    A Greater Story

    My favorite feature of my grandfather’s house in the East Lake section of Birmingham, Alabama was his upstairs closet. It tunneled from a master bedroom and emptied into a stairwell. When the adults weren’t looking, we’d wade through the clothes, boxes, and a small Christmas tree to find our way to the other side. What no one knew – except my grandfather, I presume – is that somewhere in one of his closets lay a stack of historic newspapers. “U.S. Mourns Slain President” and “Man Walks on the Moon,” both from the now-extinct Birmingham Post Herald, splashed the headlines as they emerged from an old dusty box.

    The most striking headline, on an edition of The Birmingham News, reads “GERMANY SURRENDERS!” The date? November 11, 1918. It was discovered after my grandfather died and my Mom decided to ask the history major (i.e. me) if I wanted to have it. My wife had it framed over 17 years ago and I now have it proudly displayed in my office. For years I’ve imagined the fun I would have showing it off to the world when the 100-year anniversary came around, but over this past Summer I realized there was a real problem with how I had envisioned this.

    Only the top of the front page is framed. The bottom half is not, and on the lower right side of the front page is a short but horrific article entitled, “Negro Lynched in Sheffield.” On November 10, 1918, after a policeman had been murdered, a mob took out their frustrations on a black man named Will Bird. He was not being accused of the crime (two other black men were being held in jail on suspicion), but since he had the reputation of being a “bad man” and had reportedly said he was “gonna get myself a cop,” the angry mob accepted rumor as fact and made themselves judge, jury, and executioner.  
    As much as I want to unabashedly celebrate the courage of my American ancestors, I don’t want dishonor my black brothers and sisters in Christ by neatly, and quite literally, eliminating our not-so-courageous history from the front page in the process. On the surface, you might say that this is obvious, but on further analysis, the reality is that our political tribalism actually makes it difficult to place competing narratives on the “front pages” of our discussions. For example, some of those in my tribe of conservatives will celebrate the USS Arizona Memorial because we need to make sure we “never forget,” but when slavery and lynchings are discussed, they respond with, “Why bring up the past?” Christians who are more on the liberal Democrat side, however, love to talk about the oppressed, but don’t want to talk about abortion even if they think it’s wrong. 
    It seems to me that American Christians tend to choose from one of two faulty understandings of history: the liberal Democrat view and the conservative Republican view. Each side has a fairly clear narrative –  reinforced daily through talk radio, cable news, and the echo chamber of our social media feeds – all of which insist that certain topics remain prominent while others are pushed to the back pages. Together they shape and reinforce a worldview that determines how they respond to any given issue. For the Christian, the common fault of both of these narratives is that they both focus exclusively on the history and current issues of our country alone.  In my Introduction to Christian Missions class, I teach our students to understand a person’s worldview, not simply through the religious label they give themselves (Hindu, Muslims, etc.), but by finding out what they believe about the some of great questions of life. How did we get here? What went wrong? How can it be fixed? What happens when we die? In the process, you may discover that the person who claims to be a Hindu is really more of an atheist and that, when they say “I’m Hindu,” it’s more of a cultural identity than religious statement. When we use these questions to analyze what American Christians are actually talking about and listening to on a day to day basis, however, two insidious narratives emerge which are very different from the Bible’s history of salvation. 

       To be sure, the above chart is simplified and limited in scope, but it illustrates the everyday narratives that reinforce our view of politics. To demonstrate the importance they serve in public discourse, look at what happens when one side contradicts the other’s view of The Fall. When a conservative Republican talks about the uniqueness of the American Constitution (or anything positive about the Founding Fathers), there will often be met with a swift and sharp critique from the other side that points to slavery. The assumption is that, since slavery existed, nothing from the entire era of history can be celebrated nor should it be emulated. On the other hand, bring up Thomas Jefferson’s edited Bible and you may be met with a flurry of objections from conservatives, whose worldview depends on early America consisting purely of pious, Bible-believing Christians faithfully attending church. Even though we needed two Great Awakenings in less than a century – one just before our country’s independence and one directly afterward – because of waning church attendance, deism, and general skepticism leftover from the Enlightenment (not to mention the existence of the evil of slavery!), this narrative persists. And why are the reactions so sharp from both sides? It’s simple. The foundation for all of our beliefs and actions have been threatened. 
      For the Christian, this shouldn’t be the case. We have the word of God with its sure foundation and beautiful narrative sufficient for all of life – including politics – for people from every tongue, tribe, and nation on earth. In Genesis 1 we see that, while the United States was not perfect in origin, our beautiful world was. The first human beings were created in the image of God and placed lovingly in a garden. Our problems began, not with the transcontinental slave trade, but when Adam and Eve sinned and the hearts of all subsequent generations were radically corrupted. It marred the image of their Maker and enabled every form of evil and wickedness known to human beings. God, however, did not give up on us. He called Abraham and promised that he would give him a new land, that he would become the father of a great nation, and that, through him, all families of the earth will be blessed (Genesis 12:1-3). His descendants eventually entered this Promised Land and were given clear instructions on how to glorify God and be a witness to the nations, but the evil within them prevented this from happening (Deut. 4:5-8, Romans 2:17-24). Instead, the people of Israel mistook responsibility for privilege and became centered on themselves, abandoning God’s law time and again. In his great mercy, God sent prophets to tell them to repent and to warn of impending judgment if they don’t. God led Jeremiah to prophesy that one day his law would not simply be external commands, but written on their hearts (Jeremiah 33:14-16). Isaiah predicted a suffering servant, by whose stripes we would be healed, would come to save us from our sins. Then the miracle. Jesus came to us, the word made flesh, to show us how to live and to die for our transgressions. He rose from the dead, demonstrating his power over sin and guaranteeing our own resurrection, then commanded his followers to make disciples of all the nations. After he ascended to Heaven, his followers were filled with the Holy Spirit and preached the gospel to those in Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, and began the process of spreading his word to the ends of the earth, especially through the ministry of Paul. The Bible ends with a beautiful picture of people from all tongues, tribes, and nations worshipping God around the throne just like Jesus predicted. (Matthew 24:14, Rev. 7:9-10). But the goal of history can’t be reduced to diversity. Revelation also speaks of the fall of Babylon the Great, who is said to have corrupted the world with its sexual immorality (Rev. 18:1-10). In the Bible, holiness and inclusion are not enemies.
      Since the time of the early church, the gospel of Jesus Christ has slowly made its way to the ends of the earth, even to far away countries like China and still other places that no one even knew would one day exist – like America. Sometimes it happened through the scattering and persecution of believers and sometimes through the obedience of missionaries following the call of Jesus to cross national and cultural boundaries. Today the center of gravity for the Christian faith is no longer in the West. It’s in what we call the Global South – in areas of the world below the equator, especially in Africa and parts of Asia. While many Christians in the West lament the decline of Christian influence in our culture (a tragedy over which to grieve, to be sure) we completely miss how dramatically God is still working today. Not only has the percentage of evangelical Christians remained strong in America, but more Muslims across the globe have become Christians since 9/11 than at any point in history! This is good news for Christians in a nation where we are continually warned by both sides that the end of everything good in the world is near.  
      Until Jesus returns, Christians can confidently risk honesty about the leaders and movements who represent “our side.” This is true both because we have confidence that God is in control and because our primary responsibilty isn’t fidelity to a political party. It’s faithfulness to Jesus and his beautiful gospel. I will be the first to admit that finding a balance is very confusing, and I’m certainly not advocating that we incessantly post political messages on social media, but we must try to find ways to honor the Lord in the mess that our political discourse has become. Can Republican Christians admit when our President has done or said something that contradicts Scripture or must we defend him at all cost because the next election must be won? Can Democrat Christians admit when he’s done something good or must he always be portrayed as pure evil because the next election must be won? Can we affirm the courageous self-sacrifice of the majority our police force and at the same time admit there are significant problems with bias against minorities? If we continue to cut and paste, not only will we dishonor Jesus Christ, who is the way, the TRUTH, and the life – but we also will fail to be a witness to the gospel in a world that is lost and in desperate need of Jesus.  
      The conservative Republican view only wants to see the top half of my newspaper. The liberal Democrat view only wants to see the bottom. Both are operating on the assumption that our only hope will be found in a political solution. Neither can see anything of eternal weight beyond our own borders or our own country’s history. Not only does a biblical worldview have room for both halves of the paper, but it even has leftover space for a breathtaking headline of hope. 
    “JESUS IS COMING!”

  • Smoke on the Martyrs

    Smoke on the Martyrs

    Below is an excerpt of an article I wrote that is now published at the Gospel Coalition website.

    This is difficult to write. I don’t enjoy disagreeing with those who are trying to raise awareness for the persecuted church.   We are in the midst of a clear global upsurge of attacks on Christians. In the last year we’ve seen major atrocities in Kenya, Nigeria, Libya, Syria, Iraq, Ethiopia, and other places as well. Make no mistake. The large majority of this is clearly from radical Islam and, although the majority of Muslims are not violent, an astonishingly high percentage are sympathetic to extremist violence. In the midst of this we see almost no concern on the part of the leadership of the United States. As Christians have been beheaded in dramatically produced videos designed to recruit more Muslim extremists and strike fear into the rest of the world, condemnation from the White House regarding the targeting of Christians has been underwhelming.   And in this moment when clear, consistent, and accurate voices are needed, Christians in the West are blowing a cloud of smoke into the issue by hanging their hats on a discredited and debunked statistic. There are simply not 100,000 Christian martyrs every year.

    Read the full article HERE